Best M1 Carbine Reviews with Buying Guide

The WWII glory for the Americans was the M1 Garand. This semi-automatic rifle was the reliable choice for most of the fighters. And that rifle still lives up to expectation to this date. However, it is not the only M1 that is available on the shelves at the moment. There are plenty of other versions too.

However, not all of them would be able to compete with the modern offerings of different manufacturers. And most importantly, their performance is not going to be up to par.

That is why people look for the best M1 carbine when they want to get their hands on an M1. Those are not only highly reliable but also offer stellar performance too.

Best M1 Carbine Reviews

For being highly popular, many of the firearms has got the M1 label to them. But as we have mentioned, not all of them will be worth buying. To make sure that you do not get one of them, we have gone through the top-selling models. And these are the ones that we would recommend among all of them:

1. HsaUmarex Legend Thompson M1A1 Carbine

HsaUmarex M1A1 Carbine

If you are familiar with M1 Garand, you probably already know a bit about Thompson. Yes, these were the go-to pick for SMG in the WWII era. And they still can offer superior performance, which is why we picked it for our m1 carbine reviews.

The thing that makes it different than the other versions is the overall construction. Its full metal frame willensure that it can go through rough and harsh environments without showing any issues in terms of performance and overall outlooks.You can expect to get extended use out of it.

Other than the frame, the stock, the front area, and the handle are made of wood. The wood is also high in quality, which enhances the overall durability even further. Also, the finish of the wood is pretty elegant. It will make the gun look like a relic from the past but in its out-of-the-box form.

Apart from that, the unit utilizes 2 CO2 cartridges. These are highly accessible, which will eliminate the need to go through hassles when they need replacement. Also, the placement of these is inside the magazine. And it bundles with the m1 carbine magazine.

On that note, the cartridges can fire at 435 FPS. You would get that amount of FPS in both full auto and semi-auto mode.

Highlighted Features

  • The frame is of metal
  • Features faux-wood stock and handle
  • Utilizes 2 CO2 cartridges
  • Can offer 435 FPS
  • Reasonably durable

2. Air Venturi Springfield Armory M1 Carbine

Air Venturi Springfield Armory

While there are plenty of m1 carbine rifles available, there are not that many that are tactical. However, if you were looking for one, this one should be in your consideration.

The first thing that makes this tactical m1 carbine stand out is the sight. This one offers the ability to adjust the windage on the rear sight. And for the front one, it will offer you the ability to change the position. Both the adjustments will let you finely tune the sight to get the maximum amount of precision.

On that note, the level of accuracy that this offers is exceptionally high. It would be possible for you to land the shots on target precisely for the level of accuracy it can offer. And thanks to the highly adjustable sight, tracking any acquiring targets will not be an issue either. Also, it can shoot at 425 FPS.

The magazine that it comes with utilizes the m1 carbine ammo. And with the semi-automatic nature of the gun, there will be no need to reload or pull the bolt with each of the shots you are going to take. Also, this shooting mode will make it easier for you to land shots on moving targets.

Other than that, there is a manual safety lever. That will make sure that you do not accidentally press the trigger and injure yourself or anyone around you.

Highlighted Features

  • The sight is adjustable
  • High level of accuracy
  • Semi-automatic
  • It has a manual safety lever
  • Capable of shooting at 425 FPS

3. UKARMS M1 Carbine Spring Airsoft Rifle

UKARMS M1 Spring Airsoft

So, what makes an offering the m1 carbine? If you ask us, our first answer would be reliability. Well, this one from UKARMS excels in that regard.

First of all, this modern m1 carbine features a high-capacity magazine. The magazine holds the ability to contain up to 33 rounds. That number of rounds is enough to make this one highly reliable. And there will be no need for you to reload the magazine that frequently because of its high capacity.

Another thing that the brand did not skimp on in the case of classic m1 carbine reliability is the power. This one utilizes CO2 cartridges to attain the ability to shoot 0.2 grams BBs at 300 FPS. It can shoot the lightweight ones with a higher number of FPS as well. For that reason, it will be easy to neutralize moving targets.

Other than that, the overall construction of the unit is pretty solid. It utilizes high-quality polymer for attaining the maximum level of durability. And because of how durable the unit is, it should last for an extended period of time without showing any signs of performance degradation.

Additionally, there is a safety lever, which will lock the trigger. The body also contains a fire selector, which will let you change the firing mode.

Highlighted Features

  • The magazine can hold 33 rounds
  • Utilizes highly accessible CO2 cartridges
  • Made of high-quality polymer
  • It has a trigger lock
  • Features a fire selector

M1 Carbine Buying Guide

m1 carbine reviews

We know that you are pretty excited to get one of the units we have reviewed. But before you do jump right into making a purchase decision, there are some things that you should know. Those will increase your chances of getting the m1 carbine. That being said, the points we are referring to here are:

Build Quality

The first thing that you need to consider is the build quality. In this case, you need to check the construction material. Usually, the ones that are made of high-quality materials will have a high build quality. And the ones with better build quality will last for an extended period of time without showing any issues in performance.


One of the important factors of the rifles is sight. Make sure that the one you are getting is accurate. Without having a proper level of accuracy, it will not be possible for you to land shots on the target. For that reason, our recommendation would be to put proper emphasis on the sight.

Handle / Stock

Comfortable handle and stock are a necessity for firearms. And the same thing goes for the M1 Carbine. Without having an ergonomic shape on these, it will not be possible for you to get a proper grip on the gun. Also, without an ergonomic handle, you will not be able to hold on to the gun for a long period of time.


best m1 carbine magazine

Another important thing for these is the magazine. For this, first, consider the overall capacity. Make sure that they can hold a good number of rounds, or else you will need to reload the gun quite frequently. Secondly, consider the placement CO2 cartridge. Ensure that they are on proper placement.

Safety Lever

Last but not least, check whether there is a safety lever or not. This lever will basically eliminate the chances of you accidentally pulling the trigger and injuring yourself or someone around you.

Frequently Asked Questions

1. Do all of the M1 models have higher accuracy?

Answer: M1 carbine accuracy is something that will vary from one model to another. Some will be highly accurate, while some will be reasonably less accurate.

2. Can I attach a scope with my M1 carbine?

Answer: Yes, the gun does have a rail on the top, which you can use to attach scopes. However, our recommendation would be to get the m1 carbine scope.

3. How reliable is the M1 carbine?

Answer: These are generally some of the most reliable firearms that are in existence. However, the reliability might dip down a bit with some of the particular versions.

4. Are extended magazines available for M1 Carbine?

Answer: Yes, there are extended aftermarket magazines available for the M1 Carbine. Those can bump up the ammo capacity from 20 to 40 percent.

5. How should I store my M1 carbine?

Answer: Our recommendation would be to use the m1 carbine case to store the rifle. Those would be able to keep the gun in top-notch condition for a long period of time.

Final Words

Now that you have gone through the entire article, hopefully, it is easier for you to choose the best m1 carbine. That being said, if you want us to choose one for you, we would recommend the HsaUmarex Legend Thompson M1A1. It has two firing modes, and most importantly, it pretty reliable.

Leave a Comment